Comparing MBR technology with the MBBR and CAS: how do the numbers stack up?
Using the Transcend modeling platform to benchmark conventional activated sludge with two alternative process technology options available for wastewater treatment
Sponsored content
MBR features
Search our in-depth feature articles on MBRs. Practitioners with experience of operating membrane bioreactor technology and academics researching this specialist area share their expertise.
About MBRs
A membrane bioreactor (MBR) is a wastewater treatment process where a perm-selective membrane is integrated with a biological process – a suspended growth bioreactor.
A membrane bioreactor is essentially a version of the conventional activated sludge (CAS) system. Whereas the CAS process uses a secondary clarifier or settlement tank for solid/liquid separation, an MBR uses a membrane. This provides a number of advantages relating to process control and product water quality.
Municipal & industrial treatment
There is no significant difference in the design of the MBR technology for a process treating industrial rather than municipal wastewater. The key differences between the two applications are that, for industrial effluents, there are:
- higher concentrations of organic matter
- more temporal variation in the concentrations of pollutants (seasonally and diurnally)
- very significant variations across different industrial sectors, the most biorefactory effluents being from landfill leachate applications
- no requirement for the removal of pathogenic micro-organisms, unless the effluent is combined with a sewage stream.
Highlights in this section
MBR costs
A full needs analysis is required before selecting a membrane bioreactor system, first of all to confirm that an MBR will be the most cost effective solution for a particular requirement, taking everything into account. Secondly, to ensure an MBR is the most appropriate choice of technology for the circumstances.
Highlights in this section
Design and Operation
Operation and maintenance (O&M) parameters for an MBR include:
- membrane side − flux, pressure, permeability, recovery, membrane aeration rate, and physical and chemical cleaning cycle times and protocols, and
- biological side − hydraulic and solids retention time, and sludge recycle rate(s).
Highlights in this section
Explore more content…
UWWTD and the implications of energy neutrality in wastewater treatment
The combined energy neutrality and greenhouse gas (GHG)-reduction goal for 2040, identified in the latest revision of the Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive, presents a number of quandaries...
Membrane technology in controlling micropollutants and pathogens
Read our report on 'Discussing membrane technology: micropollutants and pathogens' attended by 30 people from across the world (April 2021)
What are MBRs?
If you're new to MBRs, read our introduction to membrane bioreactors - and explore all our MBR Basics pages
Immersed flat sheet MBR membranes: a summary of commercial products
In this first of three features exploring the MBR membrane market, Simon Judd summarises characteristics of some of the commercially-available immersed flat sheet membranes for wastewater treatment