Stringing us along

06 April 2012


Simon Judd

Simon Judd

Author Bio

Simon Judd, author of The MBR Book, Watermaths, and Industrial MBRs, offers observations on membrane technology. Contact Simon at simon@juddwater.com.

There can be few things more confounding in MBR operation and maintenance than the development of filamentous bacteria in the biotank. These are “string-like” microorganisms which can normally discerned by staring down a microscope, with different species apparently prevailing under different conditions (http://santacruzproductions.com/filaments.aspx). These species are, in fact, nearly always present at some concentration, but it is only at higher levels that they start to cause problems. The most visible manifestation of the latter is the formation of a stable brown foam, sometimes called “moussing” due to its resemblance to chocolate mousse (though its olfactory properties are obviously somewhat less pleasant than that of the foodstuff).

Since the filamentous bacteria – the most prevalent species seemingly being Nocardia, Microthrix parvicella and type 021N – are hydrophobic in nature, they are also associated with membrane fouling. Thus, moussing is associated both with “poor biology” and fouling – and hence the emphasis of practitioners on “getting the biology right”. “Good biology” normally means stable operating conditions with respect to things like organic and nutrient loading, dissolved oxygen concentration, sludge concentration and temperature. So, attributes for promoting good biology do not differ so much from those associated with suppressing membrane fouling.

However, there are other string-like materials, discussed previously on this web site (http://www.thembrsite.com/feature_sludge_goes_bad.php), which do not relate at all to biology, are just as onerous, and are not readily controlled by any conventional means. The widely recognised phenomenon of “ragging” or “braiding” appears to be attributable to the agglomeration of small lengths (<10mm) of cotton wool to form long rags which can be tens of cm in length (https://www.box.net/s/rcc9ezr9g1yjde3eyvmf). These can then readily clog both the membrane channels and the membrane aerators. Little more is known about the phenomenon, but it seems unlikely that it is associated with hydrophobicity or indeed fouling: cotton wool is hydrophilic in nature and its agglomeration to form rags appears to be purely physical with no chemical or biochemical component. It is also very specific to cotton wool, and possibly other cotton derivatives: very recent work in the Catalonian region of Spain has revealed similar phenomena for an MBR fed with laundry wastewater (containing suspended lint).

‘The MBR Site’ is a trading division of Judd and Judd Ltd, a company registered in England and Wales, registered number 8082403.

Registered office: Suite 2, Douglas House, 32-34 Simpson Road, Fenny Stratford, Buckinghamshire, MK1 1BA, United Kingdom. Email: info@thembrsite.com

Banner image: full treatment plant for pharmaceutical wastewater in Taizhou, Linhai Park, Zhejiang Province, China, including Shanghai MEGAVISION  flat sheet UF membrane modules in two MBR units. Image courtesy of VALORSABIO, Lda.

Image credits:

– Image for our Chinese largest plants 全球最大的MBR项目 homepage link: Image supplied by Apex Environmental
– Image for our Consultants and Contractors homepage link: Image supplied by Ovivo USA, LLC.

Disclaimer: The information given on this website is reproduced in good faith. No liability is accepted for errors or omissions. The MBR Site does not endorse any products, services, organisations, events or any other listing included in this site. You are strongly advised to check all information, including specifications and installation details, before acting on any information given in this website. The MBR Site links to third-party websites – note that we are not responsible for the content of third-party websites and third-party websites are visited at your own risk. Please read our terms and conditions and privacy policy. Use of this website indicates acceptance of these conditions.

This website is designed for modern browsers – if you have problems viewing our website, you may wish to upgrade your browser.